I understand people like collecting stuff because they are fans, but why does Madoka get so many KA/Genga collections? The animation on the show wasn't that good. Yeah it had a few standout scenes, but that's just like most other 12 episode shows.
If it had standout scene every episode or was stylishly awesome like Kaiba or Tatami Galaxy, I could understand. I dunno, maybe I'm just looking at it wrong.
Name:
Anonymous2012-09-11 15:36
@206, Popularity? You know it's going to sell, just because it has the Madoka label on it.
Name:
Anonymous2012-09-11 15:43
Figured it'd probably be something like that.
Name:
Anonymous2012-09-11 17:06
>>206
If i'm gonna buy this one, i'll buy it just for Nozomu Abe cuts they were freaking good
Name:
Anonymous2012-09-11 17:22
More of a Imamura fan. Too bad he only did one scene in Madoka.
Name:
Anonymous2012-09-11 19:30
Horizon II ep 10 was really awesome.
Kanta Suzuki as an action director.
8 studio is the best studio.
Name:
Anonymous2012-09-11 20:23
>>207
Probably this. If there's one of the KA books worth getting it would probably episode 10's. I was sorely tempted to buy that one.
Given Takashi Hashimoto replied, could he also be part of the finale? Bari seems to be confirmed by KenO.
Name:
Anonymous2012-09-12 11:29
Why is Nichijou such a sakuga fest. I mean, I really didn't see much CG in it.
Meanwhile, Hyouka has a lot of CG. It was masked pretty well so I have no complaints but still.
So does that mean Nichijou probably had a fuckload of budget compared to Hyouka?
Name:
Anonymous2012-09-12 12:11
>>215
Rebuild has a ton of CGi, I bet that means it has a slow budget!
Name:
Anonymous2012-09-12 12:56
>>215
Hyouka is also a "sakuga fest", and good CG isn't cheap.
Name:
Anonymous2012-09-12 13:31
Yeah, speaking of that Rebuild has a lot of shitty CGi, especially in 2.0 - money wasted.
Actually, scratch that. The only good use of CGi in Rebuild was the Ramiel fight.
Fuck, I hope 3.0 gets better at it or even better, does away completely with the 3DCG. 3DCG doesn't even count as animation I say. It's puppeteering. When I watch a freaking anime, I want to see animation. If I wanted to see (virtual or otherwise) puppets, I'd watch the Muppets instead.
Name:
Anonymous2012-09-12 13:33
>216
What the fuck is a slow budget?
Name:
Anonymous2012-09-12 15:03
>>219
Similar to a low budget, except I can't type to save my life.
Name:
Anonymous2012-09-12 18:14
CG is actually rather expensive on an entry level. If you use a lot of it, it becomes cheaper: like Macross Frontier using the same mecha/Vajra models etcetera. However, doing CG angel models that will only appear in a single scene was probably more expensive than doing it in 2D. It was a (shitty) creative choice to make it look more alien.
Oh c'mon guys I didn't say Hyouka is cheap/low budget but I'm just asking was Nichijou just way beyond the budget Hyouka had?
I mean I'm just REALLY impressed with Nichijou and how it had little CG in them. IMO it almost outdone Lucky Star's outrageous scenes. It certainly is a creative outburst in the animation side.
I'm not saying Hyouka had no merits. In fact I like a lot of things about Hyouka's technical side and found it to be a step up compared to their general works.
In any case thanks for the heads up about probably CG cost.
Name:
Anonymous2012-09-12 22:38
>>224
We won't ever know the budget for both shows unless KyoAni releases the numbers. I'm pretty sure Nichijou made use of CGI as well.
Name:
Anonymous2012-09-12 23:02
The director said something like Nichijou used more drawings(per episode, I assume) than any previous KyoAni shows.
>>236
I don't think anyone here is really serious about that trailer, anyone with common sense will be reserving their judgements for when the show airs.
Name:
Anonymous2012-09-13 5:49
>>237
The one that had actual footage did have good animation.