Return Styles: Pseud0ch, Terminal, Valhalla, NES, Geocities, Blue Moon.

Pages: 1-

I discovered something horrible today.

Name: Anonymous 2008-01-27 23:33

Well, it isn't really that terrible, but it made for a good subject title. Anyway, I had been thinking about reading some or perhaps all of the books by Brandon Sanderson. Then I found out he was a Mormon.

In spite of this, are his books worth reading?

I keep on trying to tell myself that his religious beliefs probably don't factor into his books, but then I'm reminded that he's a Mormon, and anyone who believes that load of crap has to be nothing short of a colossal moron.

Am I just being intolerant? What does /book/ do when it discovers something terrible about an author it was either interested in or thought was good?

Name: Anonymous 2008-01-28 2:32

Yes you're being intolerant, but nobody's perfect.

The only unanimous opinion seems to be that the magic system in his Mistborn books kicks ass, otherwise the opinions are diverse enough to make it hard to deduce whether I'd, let alone you, like it. I have the first Mistborn book on the shelf for this very occasion. That, and because he's writing the last WoT book.

Hey, Card wrote some solid stuff before he (apparently) went nuts, so you might give Sanderson the benefit of the doubt too.

Name: Anonymous 2008-01-28 19:40

>>2

How did he go nuts? Orson Scott Card, that is.

Name: Anonymous 2008-01-31 2:07

some woman who writes dragonlance book is also mormon, but she writes magnificent fantasy

Name: Anonymous 2008-01-31 5:52

>>1
>>2
I read the first, and it wasn't bad. Not great, but if you're in need of something new, it should definitely be readable.
Also, I personally didn't notice any Mormon influence in his writing - granted, I didn't look for it, either.

About Card, see wikipedia (inb4 lulz wikipedia).


>What does /book/ do when it discovers something terrible about an author it was either interested in or thought was good?

I read about the book beforehand and if I don't discover anyone ranting about it because it allegedly has a hidden religious/political agenda, then I pirate it. I don't pay idiotic fucknuts with hilarious ideologies, at least if they're actively trying to propagate them, like Card.

Name: Anonymous 2008-01-31 13:54

Sacks of fags with bags of gags.

Name: Anonymous 2008-01-31 23:36

>Hey, Card wrote some solid stuff before he (apparently) went nuts
>>2
He may be riding the fence with a scathing opinion for any side that will listen, but I wouldn't say that he's gone over the edge. What exactly do you mean by that?

Name: Anonymous 2008-02-19 5:52

i used to listen to beck, but then i found out he was a scientologist.

it's not politically incorrect to no longer respect a person because they believe in bizarre shit.

Name: Anonymous 2008-02-22 13:35

>>8

too many negatives

Don't change these.
Name: Email:
Entire Thread Thread List