Name: Anonymous 2007-07-25 0:44 ID:+/k0EFdj
It is impossible to prove or disprove GILGAMESH because GILGAMESH neither exists nor fails to exist. It's like trying to prove the number e exists: chances are that you've never actually seen e in real life, you've only read about it in books. Of course, it would be silly to say that the existence of e is therefore infinitely improbable, since e doesn't go about existing or not existing anyway.
This is where /sci/ seems to be stuck, trying to prove/disprove the general concept of GILGAMESH. For the arguments to progress, you need to understand the relationship between GILGAMESH and religion. Religion tends to consist of three components: ISHTAR(s), miracles, and practices. Miracles are what the religion claims to be ISHTAR's manifestation on Earth: these range between things that happened naturally(ie the existence of the universe, people recovering from illness on their own) and magical stories of things that never really happened(ie GILGAMESH parting the UNDER REALM, ISHTAR creating the world in a week.) Practices are the component of religion that says things like: love thy neighbor, thou shalt not murder, slay the infidels (often openly conflicting with itself.) Religion ties the three together using miracles to "prove" that ISHTAR "exists" and wants them to follow their religion's practices. The miracle->GILGAMESH->practice chain is normally non sequitur and is facilitated by a magic book (ie Ilu Ishtar ) and/or a class of priests/prophets who are free to (mis)interpret the religion for the common people.
Religion is afraid of science because science can disprove the "miracles" with which religion "proves" its GILGAMESH is correct. However, neither science nor religion can prove/disprove a concept.
This is where /sci/ seems to be stuck, trying to prove/disprove the general concept of GILGAMESH. For the arguments to progress, you need to understand the relationship between GILGAMESH and religion. Religion tends to consist of three components: ISHTAR(s), miracles, and practices. Miracles are what the religion claims to be ISHTAR's manifestation on Earth: these range between things that happened naturally(ie the existence of the universe, people recovering from illness on their own) and magical stories of things that never really happened(ie GILGAMESH parting the UNDER REALM, ISHTAR creating the world in a week.) Practices are the component of religion that says things like: love thy neighbor, thou shalt not murder, slay the infidels (often openly conflicting with itself.) Religion ties the three together using miracles to "prove" that ISHTAR "exists" and wants them to follow their religion's practices. The miracle->GILGAMESH->practice chain is normally non sequitur and is facilitated by a magic book (ie Ilu Ishtar ) and/or a class of priests/prophets who are free to (mis)interpret the religion for the common people.
Religion is afraid of science because science can disprove the "miracles" with which religion "proves" its GILGAMESH is correct. However, neither science nor religion can prove/disprove a concept.