>>51,52
Perhaps your disagreement is best explained this way: the definition of "weeaboo" varies from board to board. For /a/, /jp/ and the related, a weeaboo is someone who watches animu/plays H-games/reads manga, but for /b/ and most people a weeaboo is a wapanese. So
>>51 is from the /b/ side of 4chin and doesn't see himself as weeaboo since he isn't fapping on a map of japan, but
>>52 is most likely from one of the animu-derived boards and considers
>>51 a weeaboo because he likes fappan gaems CG and is familiar with animu.