Return Styles: Pseud0ch, Terminal, Valhalla, NES, Geocities, Blue Moon.

Pages: 1-

sound systems in slackware linux

Name: Anonymous 2006-10-03 2:15

OSS, ALSA, ARTS, ESS (or is it ESD?), yada yada yada.  Makes my head spin as to what's what and what I really need and what's deprecated or if I need all of them, etc....

Which one should I go with for maximum compatibility?  Can I have all of them loaded without hardware conflicts?  Some applications say they use OSS, some say they use ALSA, some say you need to run with artsdsp (the only way I've found to get Flash to use sound, although it's VERY laggy, like 1 and a half second sound lag, grr)....etc.

I don't even have an idea what my system is using now, and I consider myself pretty Linux savvy when it comes to most things... just not audio hardware.

For the record, most programs recognize sound.  Doom 3, Quake 4, schism tracker, even a dinky little synthesizer I wrote in Common LISP one weekend.  But Flash doesn't, so I figure I might have overlooked something in setting up my audio.

And.....hmm.....I hate the thought of abandoning Slackware, which is the distro I've used ever since it was in its 3.x days.... buuuuut anyone have any recommendations for other Linux distros that are built around higher hardware compatibility?  I also have a Wacom tablet that X.org tends to misbehave with sometimes (works fine in GIMP, strangely enough, but anywhere else the cursor "skips" real fast when the stylus touches the pad)... so yeah.

Name: Anonymous 2006-10-03 4:25

>OSS, ALSA, ARTS, ESS (or is it ESD?), yada yada yada.  Makes my head spin as to what's what and what I really need and what's deprecated or if I need all of them, etc....

What do you use as your desktop? If you use KDE you have ARTS by default. Esound is really shitty (has never really worked for me) and I always use OSS over it.

The only real applications I've really used are gmplayer and xmms; and when I'm outside of KDE I usually look for the OSS setting in whatever preference dialog the app has.

Arts *appears* to support network streaming (play a media file on computer 1, hear it on computer 2); but I've never tried that out much so I can't tell you anything more about it.

Hope that helped; if it didn't...just goes to show free advice is worth what you pay for it.

Name: Anonymous 2006-10-03 4:26

>>2
I forgot to mention, I'm also familiar with slackware (used it from 3.3 - 7.0 and I'm currently running 10.2).

Name: Anonymous 2006-10-03 5:31

>>1,2,3

ALSA

Name: Anonymous 2006-10-03 8:06

>>4

SIGNED

Although ARTs is a complete nightmare with conflicts, i cant seem to get ALSA to coexist happily with ARTs

For instance (under KDE) if im running XmmS using ALSA and a window changes just as the song changes, ARTs will RAEP my sound.

Im basicly forced to use ARTs plugins with any app if i want to hear anything.

Name: Anonymous 2006-10-03 18:52

OSS is deprecated. ESD is deprecated(does Enlightenment even use it anymore?) ARTS is a pile of shit. Unfortunately if you use kde you have to use ARTS. KDE4 will see the end of ARTS thank god.  Oh and uhhh....XFCE ftw.

Name: Anonymous 2006-10-04 13:51

when will KDE4 be out?

SOOOON hopefully cause ARTs fucks with my junk man.

Name: Anonymous 2006-10-04 14:15

http://developer.kde.org/development-versions/kde-4.0-release-plan.html

hopefully this Phonon crap wont be a similar failure. I'm too lazy to actually read about it though.
http://phonon.kde.org/

Name: Anonymous 2006-10-05 7:05

Phonon sounds bad man, it sounds to me like ARTs fat ugly beefer of a friend, coupled with the added headache of fucking up my video shit too :(

I smell HUEG BLOATWARE thats a nightmare to remove or work around :(

Don't change these.
Name: Email:
Entire Thread Thread List