implying half of the cuts in that trailer aren't missing inbetweens implying any cut in that trailer went through post-processing implying that isn't an animatic that's just touched up in places
Why would a high action scene have slower timing than a baby crawling on the floor or a girl looking out the window? There's no way that trailer isn't using work in progress material.
Yeah, keep trolling. Or go back to school. Seems you fail at reading comprehension big time. I wouldn't be surprised if you're the same shitstain who shitposts about sales in here.
missing inbetweens
What? Most of that trailer is on 1s and 2s bro. post-processing
I don't see why it wouldn't have. The colors are balanced, the lighting is already on place.
The first trailer is a scene in a different place, at a different point in the film, probably made by a different animator. If your problem are the rough b&w trees, I'm sorry but you'll be disappointed because it's supposed to look like that. If you have another specific problem, please elaborate.
Name:
Anonymous2013-10-23 11:10
KyoAni should be a taboo studio since they're nothing special anyway.
It feels like everyone has their Haruhi goggles too tight.
Name:
Anonymous2013-10-23 11:11
The green frame should be a dead giveaway that this is WIP. The sideways running cut 18 seconds in has incomplete background art. Same with the cut 24 seconds in, which is also missing inbetweens. The cut 36 seconds in uses incomplete background art. It's also not the final photography and has no harmony layer. The run into the moon at the end is also incomplete - you can even see the details fading in as the cut progresses similar with the 10 second house CM trailer (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OQzW8ZUPw-s). Just look at the sides to spot it.
The only cut that seems to be close to its final form is the run through the forest. I suspect they'll only add some subtle effects to it, seems complete otherwise.
If you seriously think this is the final version of the footage you're retarded. Takahata like gowing against the stream, but he's not stupid. People would be walking out of the theatre if they showed them an incomplete work like this.
>>660
The green frame was not there in the original broadcast (I watched the .ts), the taiwanese cappers added it because they're retarded like that.
I'll give you the 24sec cut (though it could, again, be a problem with the cap and it looks like that), but the others are finished. Perhaps they will add some subtle digital effects, but I'm pretty sure you're seeing what you'll get. The BG at 18secs looked like that in the PR photos they released, they wouldn't use WIP for that (and none of the other photos were WIP). The cut at 36secs has some jitter at the background, but it doesn't look bad to me. The grass is obviously animated and intentionally drawn like that for effect.
The BG at 18secs looked like that in the PR photos they released
It didn't. The PR photo didn't have the BG layer.
Cap problems or WIP, I hope and really think the film doesn't look like this. I will eat my balls if it does. I don't think Takahata is aiming for Windy Tales here.
I don't think Takahata is the main responsible for the visual style of the film. He has to approve it, yes, but it looks just like Osamu Tanabe's beverage commercials, polished to feature film-level. If you don't like it, well, that's too bad, but if you had no problem with the other bits of footage they released it could just be a problem you have with this scene (the trailer seems to be a single, long scene) and not the entire film.
Name:
Anonymous2013-10-23 12:16
Ok. KnK 4 done. I'm prepared to drop this show.
Nothing really good coming out this season.
Name:
Anonymous2013-10-23 12:17
Yeah, so far the only thing that impressed me was Takeuchi's cut in Yuushibu 1.
Name:
Anonymous2013-10-23 12:19
Or maybe you guys are just finally seeing KyoAni for what they really are. A so-so studio with no versatility.
Name:
Anonymous2013-10-23 12:29
>>628 Kill la Kill? Not really, still waiting for something impressive. It's stylish but kinda cheap too
Dafuq?
Are you talking about the animation or are you one of the other dozens of tards that mix the animation with everything else in the show and complain about it in an animation thread? Just like >>668
Name:
Anonymous2013-10-23 12:31
Nobody gives a shit about what shows you're watching or dropping. This is the animation appreciation thread. Either talk about animation, or fuck off.
Yes, go on. "Dafuq?" what? Are you seriously trying to say Kill la Kill's animation was impressive in any way? That whole show is carried by the layouts and art direction. Not the animation, with its crap CG and digital tweens.
They really don't have versatility in a way that they can't handle this kind of genre animation wise. Only a few of them can probably come up with something good. That fucking escalator scene had some bogus cuts that look weird.
Name:
Anonymous2013-10-23 12:46
>>672
Episode 1 has good animation by Takafumi Hori.
Episode 2 was pretty shit.
Episode 3 has 2 awesome transformation scene and the action is great, better than KnK, in fact.
Name:
Anonymous2013-10-23 12:47
I guess Kyoani just isn't really capable when it comes to action. Takemoto is awesome but ep 4 was just so boring. The layouts and staging for the action lacked any sort of energy, and the digital camerawork was deplorable. Though I actually liked the small bits in ep 1 when the youmu showed up at the end. The editing and quick cuts between shots was exciting. Maybe Ishidate is better at this stuff than Takemoto is? His episodes have been really disappointing
Name:
Anonymous2013-10-23 12:53
At any rate, we should wait for the Kigami episode. If someone can make good action out of this it's him.
Name:
Anonymous2013-10-23 12:57
Without Ishidate being available for KA, I'm setting expectations at minimum.
Name:
Anonymous2013-10-23 13:09
What's wrong with the action animation in KnK again?
Totally. The scream louder in Kill la Kill, and that translates into better animation. The fuck are you talking about? Besides Honda's transformation the only good cut of animation in episode 3 was that scene with Mako's dad and brother running around the room, not the crap action scenes.