Ep 3 of free has some really nice cuts. Haruka's dive was done really well and Rei's vault at the end reminded me of the awesome Chan-mio cut in Nichijou.
>>662
No kidding. You sure you didn't skip a bunch of frames while making that gif?
Name:
Anonymous2013-07-18 10:24
>>663
my guess is that the key-animator did a good job, and the in-betweener fucked it up.
Name:
Anonymous2013-07-18 10:27
>>664
why would the key-animator skip all these frames and hand it over to the in-betweener? It's water FX, not detailed character drawings where the character is just standing around.
Name:
Anonymous2013-07-18 10:29
No Kigami to show the ropes in episode 3
Name:
Anonymous2013-07-18 11:19
In case you haven't noticed, KyoAni animation always looks skippy/jerky.
Name:
Anonymous2013-07-18 11:27
>>667
That has nothing to do with it. The animation timing in that water splash scene does look completely messed up.
Name:
Anonymous2013-07-18 11:50
>>668
Care to explain what is wrong with the timing?
>>699
Just looks at real water splash movements in 12fps, and you will understand.
Name:
Anonymous2013-07-18 14:07
>>671
I still don't understand.
guess i'm not sakuga enough XD
Name:
Anonymous2013-07-18 15:57
>>669
The way the water moves doesn't make any sense. It's completely unnatural. Basically it has the traits of bad animation (or animation where something has gone seriously wrong down the line).
That's the best way I can explain it.
Name:
Anonymous2013-07-18 16:27
No, it's fucked up like that in the actual episode.
Kyoani dun goofed.
Name:
Anonymous2013-07-18 16:52
>>662
I'm not the dude who stated the message but yeah it's pretty bad
also the first splash is kinda ok , but the second spalsh is AWFUL and STUPID
too fast , need work , look at the Okiura film gif , the ending is way better , fully ended , harmonic , beautiful and accordingly drawn.
Damned kyoani
Name:
Anonymous2013-07-18 17:32
This is why experienced sakuga fans don't think that Free! is a top-tier sakuga show
Top Tier:
>Uchouten Kazoku
High Tier:
>Love Lab
>Monogatari season 2
>Tamayura
>>675
Both splashes have the same issue, it goes down too fast and the timing is plain wrong. It really does feel like the it's missing in-betweens.
Kyoani being Kyoani, they'll probably correct it for the BDs.
Name:
Anonymous2013-07-18 18:28
>>678
More than missing in-betweens, I think the key frames look misplaced. Which is the reason why the scene gives the impression that the timing is fucked up. If they were simply missing in-betweens the timing would still look reasonable.
Name:
Anonymous2013-07-18 18:33
Kyoani being Kyoani, they'll probably correct it for the BDs