>>9, >>6 here.
>>6 would like to say that he is neither on
>>1's nor
>>5's side. Rather, he is on the "I can't believe I bought that book, I hate Terry Brooks" side.
But if I had to choose, I'd somewhat aggree with
>>5. People only care about what did it best; Eragon < Star Wars, and on the GENERAL CONCENSUS, Star Wars > Dune. Still, most Dune-lovers are either too careless or two wise to whine about Star Wars' (sorta) plagiarism. From my perspective, many Dune fans are also Star Wars fans anyway.
ps did you know that Eragon is dragon except with 1 higher value in hex code (truth)