Making a game review show.

I'm in the pre-production stage of making a video game review show. I may expand to include reviews of peripherals and anime as well but for now, it's just video games. It will be about 5-10 minutes long per episode and cover one specific game.

I'm sort of stuck as for a review formula though. I was thinking of making it a good review/bad review thing where one person gives all of good things and says it's a good game. The other anchor will say all the bad things about it and give it a poor review. Then they can bicker back and forth about it.

I'm just not sure how well something like that would work out and want some opinions. So, against my better judgement, I'll ask 4chan.

What do you think, 4chan?

>>7

That's an awesome idea! I can get people to comment themselves through MP3 audio files which they could send me. I wouldn't ask anyone to send me any video files though. They are either large or look like crap. I have my own equipment and know-how for capturing high quality video game footage.

When I go to broadcast this out, I will want the highest quality footage available to me and it's easier to just do it myself.

This also allieviates the nessicity of having to get together two extra people for each show. Another problem with this production is a set. My apartment space and light isn't suitable for a quality production. I could overlay video game footage with commentary that people send me over the 'net instead.

While this would make it easier to a point, a new issue that arises is how I would get these audio files from people in the first place? I mean, I could make a post on 4chan or GameFAQs forums or something but despite the popularity, I doubt a lot of people are going to reply, much less intelligently.

A related issue is also with quality control. Most people only have a headset mic for teamspeak and in most cases, the quality provided from these is quite poor.

=/

Any further ideas?