Return Styles: Pseud0ch, Terminal, Valhalla, NES, Geocities, Blue Moon. Entire thread

Sneaky Internal State

Name: Anonymous 2012-03-28 23:59

I've boiled what I want out of a programming language down to a single example.  Problems like this bite me in the ass often and I haven't used a language, yet, that helps.

Suppose I'm writing a library for working with vectors.  For simplicity, it's not fancy n-dimensional vectors, etc., let's say just three floats.  So I write some code to perform operations on vectors, like add, subtract, dot product, cross product, rotate, scale... and then I come to "normalize."

Here, I come up with this optimization that vectors could also store a flag indicating whether or not they are normal.  If that flag is set, then normalize has no work to do.  The catch is that I have to decide which operations clear the flag, which operations set it, and which operations leave it unchanged.  So I do the work and end up with a nice, efficient vector library.

I use my library for a long time -- long enough that I stop caring how that optimization worked.  Eventually, months later, I decide to add some new functions to my vector library.  Of course, I've forgotten all about the "normal" flag, and I forget to set/clear it in the new functions.  Of course, there's no compile error or even a run-time error.  I just observe strange behavior when the application runs and I have to spend hours stepping through floating-point math to figure out what's wrong.

How does your language of choice improve this situation?

Name: Anonymous 2012-03-29 1:17

>>12
But the flag for checking if it is normalized is shitty. Think about all the time that will be spent updating and checking that flag.
Nah, that's exactly the point of the optimization...  It's a single memory comparison.  Without the flag, figuring out whether or not a 3D vector is normalized involves floating-point math and a lot more than a single memory comparison.

Regardless, let me say again that this one optimization is just an example, and what I'm looking for is a programming language feature that somehow makes "sneaky internal state" like this more explicit or less error prone.

Newer Posts
Don't change these.
Name: Email:
Entire Thread Thread List