assignment thread #201527

This assignment question keeps haunting me, and the professor stubbornly refuses to give us any hint.

Given a cipher mode (here referred to as "DBC", or double block chaining) as shown in the diagrams located at the bottom of my post, a function DBC-encrypt(E,IV,p) which encrypts plaintext p using initialization vector IV and symmetric cipher E, and a function DBC-decrypt(D,IV,c) which decrypts ciphertext c using initialization vector IV and symmetric cipher D (where D is the inverse of E for a given key), prove that the following authenticated encryption scheme is not secure, given that the underlying cipher E/D is secure and IVs are unique:

AE-DBC-encrypt(E,IV,m)
    EIV <- E(IV)
    c <- DBC-encrypt(E, EIV, m || IV)
    return (EIV, c)

AE-DBC-decrypt-and-authenticate(E,EIV,c)
    plaintext <- DBC-decrypt(D, EIV, c)
    m <- all-but-last-block(plaintext)
    checksum <- last-block(plaintext)
    if checksum == D(EIV) then
        return m
    else
        return null
    end

Note that IV is not transmitted, only E(IV).


Diagrams:




>>15
Usenet at least had this automated. But some simple userscript can reassemble and display the files easily.
The only thing which i'm afraid, is that may be banned for spamming so much posts.