Souls and God

Now I haven't read much about logic or stuff so if someone could formulate my problem with a better language I'd be thrilled.
Let's say God is omniscient.
Because of his omniscience he will only act in one way, seeing how he's because of mentioned omniscience seeing himself act in the future, now and the past.
Now let's take a soul.
God is the creator of all souls, since he is the creator of everything. Which means that he makes a conscious decision when creating a particular soul. Because of his omniscience he will see this souls future before he's even created it, he will see whether or not this soul will sin or not.
Now here comes my point:
If God is truly omniscient, then why does he knowingly create souls that inevitably will sin and revolt against God, thus being condemned to hell?
The way one can explain this is if God's either not:
Omniscient

or

All benevolent

What do you guys think?
Did I think it through this time?

The need for proof is ABSOLUTE

Fail. There are many ways of looking at the world where proof is irrelevant. You just, er, religiously believe in the scientific paradigm even though all proof is based on an unprovable set of assumptions in this paradigm.

Take those religifags and tell them they don't require proof in their daily lives

Fail. Daily life =/= an analogy for theories on the existence of God.

ouch RedCream, I really exposed your fail there, sorry about that.