I don't know about anyone else, but I found JRR Tolkien's book really dull and reading it was a real chore. Big props to Peter Jackson for turning it into a highly watchable trilogy.
Name:
Anonymous2005-01-03 16:26
The ending of the books was an anticlimax. It was also amazingly annoying.
I will never understand why they are held in such high regard. The world was carefully developed and linguists will enjoy a fair bit of the material, but the pacing was poor and the characterization ridiculous. If you ripped the plot and characters out you could transplant them in a children's story. Yet the book is too dense for a child. So what exactly was the target audience?
Certainly, it's modelled quite well after some classic epics, but it's a bore as well. I suppose they're like Ulysses: completely overrated.