Welp, the old thread suddenly got spammed to hell and back. Though it says something when we've managed to keep it active for about two and a half years after I initially started this challenge, so maybe it was time for change anyways.
Therefore, this will be the new Amagami Challenge thread from now on.
Guy who made the original poster here.
I had totally forgotten about the Amagami Challenge till I went looking through my old pictures folder today. I hadn't realized it but the changes I did (clothes getting out more etc) stuck around since I failed it the first year this started. Its a good thing they did because I was lucky enough to have completed the challenge last year.
Best of luck to you guys.
Also: I'd be willing to update the poster with suggestions or just even change the year if you guys are interested. You can just post them here and I'll check it out in a week or two.